Blue Line Sports II - NEW Decision 01.29.2025
Decision and Order of Judge Ellis, NYS Supreme Court, Franklin County, issued January 29, 2025 in favor of Petitioners Blue Line Sports and Woods & Waters to defeat the State’s motion to dismiss. The State now has 30 days to answer the petition, or, to file a notice of appeal.
The Decision and Order fills a gap in precedent under NY CPLR 2304 by distinguishing between filing “thereafter” to quash an extra-judicial subpoena versus filing “promptly” to quash a litigation subpoena. The ruling is not limited to NYS-licensed “Dealers in Firearms,” such as petitioners.
This is the second ruling concerning these petitioners. The prior ruling in Blue Line Sports I issued October 7, 2024, is an interesting companion read for those studying NY CPLR 2304 motions to quash subpoenas.
This is a FREE download of 11-pages.
There is a BLOG also written about the Decision and Order.
The Blue Line Sports I decision and order of 10.07.2024 is HERE.
The example extra-judicial subpoena to Blue Line Sports is HERE.
Decision and Order of Judge Ellis, NYS Supreme Court, Franklin County, issued January 29, 2025 in favor of Petitioners Blue Line Sports and Woods & Waters to defeat the State’s motion to dismiss. The State now has 30 days to answer the petition, or, to file a notice of appeal.
The Decision and Order fills a gap in precedent under NY CPLR 2304 by distinguishing between filing “thereafter” to quash an extra-judicial subpoena versus filing “promptly” to quash a litigation subpoena. The ruling is not limited to NYS-licensed “Dealers in Firearms,” such as petitioners.
This is the second ruling concerning these petitioners. The prior ruling in Blue Line Sports I issued October 7, 2024, is an interesting companion read for those studying NY CPLR 2304 motions to quash subpoenas.
This is a FREE download of 11-pages.
There is a BLOG also written about the Decision and Order.
The Blue Line Sports I decision and order of 10.07.2024 is HERE.
The example extra-judicial subpoena to Blue Line Sports is HERE.
Decision and Order of Judge Ellis, NYS Supreme Court, Franklin County, issued January 29, 2025 in favor of Petitioners Blue Line Sports and Woods & Waters to defeat the State’s motion to dismiss. The State now has 30 days to answer the petition, or, to file a notice of appeal.
The Decision and Order fills a gap in precedent under NY CPLR 2304 by distinguishing between filing “thereafter” to quash an extra-judicial subpoena versus filing “promptly” to quash a litigation subpoena. The ruling is not limited to NYS-licensed “Dealers in Firearms,” such as petitioners.
This is the second ruling concerning these petitioners. The prior ruling in Blue Line Sports I issued October 7, 2024, is an interesting companion read for those studying NY CPLR 2304 motions to quash subpoenas.
This is a FREE download of 11-pages.
There is a BLOG also written about the Decision and Order.
The Blue Line Sports I decision and order of 10.07.2024 is HERE.
The example extra-judicial subpoena to Blue Line Sports is HERE.
